Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Kyle Young's avatar

No one knows the situation better and has more experience with all of it than you. If I were you, I'd be leaning heavily on my intuition right now.

Expand full comment
Diana's avatar

Can we help you clarify the situation? I'm going to ask you a whole bunch of clarifying questions. Many of them are unthinkable. Many of them will seem outrageous. I don't know you, or your family, or the Thai culture. What you describe is clearly very very upsetting. It seems you are hoping for a good outcome. It seems terribly hard not to be able to trust and rely on your family! I will try to think with you about this situation. REMEMBER, though. I can't tell you what you should do.

THE QUESTION

Ka, your husband, has been "kidnapped by his brother Tee." Should you send him ransom money? Can you? Do you have $50 to send? Will that be enough? What you want to decide is should you send money to Ka?

FIRST: What happens to Ka if you don't send it? You didn't discuss this outcome. Does Tee harm Ka? Does Ka lose his job? (Is he unemployed.)

Further discussion: Why is Ka so eager to get money? It sounds like Tee is the one who really needs the money. Does Tee owe money to the Thai mafia? Will the mafia harm Tee if Ka doesn't pay Tee?

You say Tee kidnapped Ka. How does Tee prevent Ka from leaving?

You say Tee is an addict. You have given Tee money previously (I'm not rereading your post correct me if I'm wrong.) Tee has stolen possessions from you. Tee has lied to you and to Ka and to the mafia. The mafia is bad. Is Tee also "bad" (meaning untrustworthy)? I don't think Tee is uncomfortable with taking your money and lying and/or stealing. It seems he has done this before.

Tee wants to be able to do what he wants with no consequences or responsibilities. In fact he probably doesn't think of drugs and consequences in the same thought. Probably all he thinks is "I REALLY REALLY need to take drugs because I'm feeling bad" (unhappy victim) AND THEN "I REALLY REALLY need money to pay off my drug dealers or I will get hurt (unhappy victim) But he never puts drug use together with its consequences.

He has gotten in trouble with the Thai Mafia before. PREDICTION: Tee is an addict. He will be unable to control his addiction (based on past history). The Mafia will, therefore, always be a threat to you and Ka because of Tee.

Does Tee promise to reform? Does Ka hope Tee will behave and plead with you on Tee's behalf?

Is sending the money the end of the matter?

MY CONCLUSION

Tee is on a repetitive treadmill. Needs drug. Has no money. Borrows money from the Mafia (or steals from them. to get drugs) Mafia threatens him when he fails to repay them. He promises he will get the money. Eventually, he gets it from Ka--and then from you if Ka has no money. You are too scared of the Mafia to refuse him. He pays off the Mafia. NOW RETURN TO BEGINNING OF THIS PARAGRAPH AND KEEP REPEATING

You can't get Tee to stop. He and the Mafia are happy because they can rely on you and Ka to fund Tee's addiction. You are thinking Tee will say "That was a close call! I avoided the Mafia by the skin of my teeth. I'm ashamed that I lost control of my drug addiction. I'm ashamed that I put my brother and sister in law in peril. I am so grateful they bailed me out (again). I will never do anything like this again." (until next time)

Tee is deluded (majority of addicts are deluded). He will be happy and grateful that you bailed him out. WHEW! Need some drugs to celebrate! OR Need some drugs to feel better because of depression. Can't function without drugs. Jealous of you and Ka. You OWE him this money because he's an unhappy Mafia victim and life has dealt him a raw deal.

Ask your friends and relatives what they think. What does Ka say? Ask him if he is scared of the Mafia. Ask him if he thinks Tee will pay off the Mafia or spend your money on drugs. Ask him if he is free to leave. I don't think you can talk to Tee or the Mafia. They will do what they can to get more and more money from you. Maybe Tee has also managed to convince Ka that this time will go better.

I'm so sorry for everybody. I recently read a Meme which showed graffiti reading "Life is pain." Another graffiti artist appended, "AU CHOCOLAT." It now reads: "Life is pain AU CHOCOLAT."

Are you the golden goose, the horn of plenty, the magic fairy? Once they realize you will do everything possible to give them money, they will never stop. Do you agree?

Is Ka deluded? Is he able to think past this crisis? Do Tee and Ka think only in the short term (most addicts don't have long range plans--they are using drugs to cope in the short term.) In that case Ka is really upset that his brother is hurting (is Tee also going through withdrawal?). Maybe Ka feels responsible? Ask Ka why he thinks you should give Tee money. Because it worked so well previously?

Oh Amy, the only thing I believe is that you can't trust Tee or the Mafia. Use your money to help Ka leave Tee and separate himself from Tee who seems a bad influence.

I know that's what you're trying to do. One thing you could do is interview someone who knows the mafia to find out what is most likely to happen if Tee doesn't pay off his debt. No chance of treatment for Tee? Does Tee even WANT to get rehabilitated? Ka has known Tee longer than you have. Does he trust him?

You didn't mention this, but can you appeal to the police? Are they corrupt? If I were the police I would have trouble believing that a brother could kidnap his brother and demand ransom from his sister in law. The fact that Ka is demanding the money seems terribly suspicious. Do you ever talk to Tee? What does Tee tell you? Can you threaten Tee that you will have him arrested (possession of drugs) if he bothers you?

What do you think of risk/benefit ratio for mRNA Covid vaccines?

What do you think of risk/benefit ratio for eating a sugary donut one time? Or getting regular nights of sleep?

What do you think of risk/benefit ratio of paying ransom money to Tee?

What good thing (benefit) is likely to happen if you give Ka and Tee $50?

Tee and Ka will be happy.

Ka will return to you.

Tee will pay off his debt.

Tee will control his drug use or other expenses so he doesn't have to ask you for more money

What's the risk for giving Tee money?

You lose your money

Tee needs more money and kidnaps Ka again--and you are in the same situation again

What good thing (benefit) will happen from NOT giving Ka and Tee $50?

You won't lose your money.

Tee is less likely to ask you again for money.

What's the risk of NOT giving money to Ka and Tee?

You didn't save Ka and will feel guilty for not trusting him and his brother

The Mafia will harm Tee or Ka.

You have to face uncomfortable truths--can you trust your family?

Ka will never forgive you and you will experience severe marital conflict which is awful because you love your husband.

Whatever you decide to do--Thank you for your substack. Also: You seem like a wonderful person and wife.

Expand full comment
40 more comments...

No posts